The witchy sequel recouped only $46 million of its estimated $75 million budget — but will it find lasting power at the box office?

*Practical Magic 2 *breaks the spell *Spider-Man *and *The Odyssey *held over the box office, but fails to conjure a profit

The witchy sequel recouped only $46 million of its estimated $75 million budget — but will it find lasting power at the box office?

By Ryan Coleman

Ryan Coleman

Ryan Coleman is a news writer for with previous work in MUBI Notebook, Slant, and the LA Review of Books.

EW's editorial guidelines

September 13, 2026 7:17 p.m. ET

Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman in ‘Practical Magic 2’. Credit:

Courtesy Warner Bros. Pictures

- *Practical Magic 2 *is the new queen in town after ousting both *The Odyssey* and *Spider-Man: Brand New Day* from their long-held spots at the top of the box office.

- Warner Bros.’ sequel to the 1998 classic easily overtook its competitors this weekend, but $46 million globally isn’t a great opening take for a film that cost $75 million to produce.

- Next week, Zach Cregger’s *Resident Evil *will attempt to claw its way to the top spot.

After nine weeks of undisputed dominance, *The Odyssey** *and *Spider-Man: Brand New Day** *have fallen to a witchy new foe. But *Practical Magic 2*’s spell over the box office may not have been cast to last.

Director Susanne Bier and co-writers Akiva Goldsman, Georgia Pritchett, and Kelly Marcel’s spellbinding sequel to the 1998 classic directed by Griffin Dunne and written by Goldsman, Robin Swicord, and Adam Brooks conjured up $30 million domestically and $46 million globally this week, per box office tracker Rentrak.

Those sums were more than enough to knock Matt Damon’s Odysseus and Tom Holland’s Spidey down a peg, securing the witchy Owens women, led by Nicole Kidman and Sandra Bullock, a No. 1 film at home and abroad. That’s a win for Warner Bros., which took a gamble on the sequel nearly 30 years in the making. But the studio may not be viewing its odds so favorably.

Matt Damon in ‘The Odyssey’; Tom Holland in ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’.

Melinda Sue Gordon/Universal Pictures; Jay Maidment

Sure, *The Odyssey *fell to No. 3 with $7.4 million domestically and $34.4 million around the world. But that’s after an astonishing nine weeks in theaters. The star-studded adaptation of Homer’s seafaring epic currently boasts over $600 million in the former market, placing it second behind *Brand New Day *in the overall domestic leaderboard for 2026, and a whopping $1.68 billion in the latter market — ditto on the global rankings.

As for *Brand New Day*, Holland’s fourth outing as the web-slinger has shattered records virtually every week since its early August opening. The film added $8.4 million domestically and $27.4 million globally this weekend, making for $935.1 million overall in the former market and $2.45 billion in the latter.

Bier, Warners, and even Kidman and Bullock (who serve as producers) certainly didn’t expect their sister witches to seriously contend with a behemoth IP like Spider-Man. But $46 million is a worrying start for a film made on an estimated $75 million budget, especially considering that the cost of the film’s marketing blitz isn’t factored into that estimate.

‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ and ‘The Odyssey’ boost 2026 domestic box office to best-ever summer

‘Practical Magic 2’: All the callbacks to the original you missed in the sequel

But all may not be lost for *Practical Magic 2*. It’s sure to recoup at least its budget within the next couple weeks, and as Paul Dergarabedian, Rentrak’s Head of Marketplace Trends, noted in a Sunday interview with AP, “It’s not necessarily about that opening weekend... Weekend two will tell the tale, no question about it.” *Practical Magic 2 *is “the kind of movie that you can build an evening at the movie theater around with your friends,” one that may find a lasting place at the movieplex.

Elsewhere on the weekend’s box office leaderboards, the independent Christian outfit Angel Studios misfired with *Runner*, a thriller starring Alan Ritchson as a former soldier racing to save a child’s life as a drug cartel closes in. The film opened to $6.6 million domestically atop a budget estimated between $35-45 million.

*Coyote vs. Acme*, however, once seen as little more than a victim of studio cruelty, has proven an enduring hit, adding another $6.2 million to its domestic coffers, which now reach $47.7 million.

***Get your daily dose of entertainment news, celebrity updates, and what to watch with our ******EW Dispatch newsletter******.***

Next week, Zach Cregger returns just over a year after his bizarro *Weapons *became a centerpiece of the 2025 horror conversation. His take on *Resident Evil** *will play against Ethan Hawke’s historical drama *The Weight *— as well as *Practical Magic 2*, *Brand New Day*, and *The Odyssey*, of course, for the box office gold.

- Movie Reviews & Recommendations

- Movie Industry

Original Article on Source

Source: “EW Box”